Best Stock Market Simulator Apps

A good stock trading simulator allows you to dip your toes in investing & trading without risking a penny. Unlike regular paper trading accounts, the best stock market simulator apps are also fun to use.

Depuis 2015, nous avons testé plus de 150 jeux de simulateur de trading pour vous aider à choisir le meilleur en fonction de vos compétences et de vos objectifs d'investissement.

Sur la base de nos derniers tests, voici les 11 meilleurs jeux de simulation boursière :

  1. Trois Investisseurs - iOS | Android
  2. Investopedia Simulator - Web
  3. Best Brokers Simulator -  iOS | Android
  4. Invstr - iOS | Android
  5. Thinkorswim de TD Ameritrade - Web
  6. Line Century Simulator - iOS
  7. Formateur de stock - Android
  8. HowTheMarketWorks - Web
  9. Ninja Trader - Web
  10. TradeStation - Version web
  11. Invest Stock Market Simulator - iOS

Quel est le meilleur simulateur de marché boursier ?

Le tableau ci-dessous résume les recherches qui comparent la 3 most popular stock market simulator apps.

La comparaison est basée sur 10 facteurs clés : la fonctionnalité de négociation, la recherche sur les actions, les retards de prix en temps réel, la gestion des risques, le choix des actifs, la valeur éducative, les concours et le divertissement, les indicateurs, la gestion de portefeuille et le prix du simulateur.

Best stock market simulator apps comparison

Le meilleur simulateur boursier selon l'analyse des 10 facteurs est le suivant Jeu boursier des trois investisseurs. Il ne dispose pas des meilleurs outils de recherche boursière, mais son graphique en direct, son école de trading interactive et ses concours de classement addictifs font que son expérience utilisateur se distingue des autres.

Le site Simulateur Investopedia est le plus célèbre de son genre. Toutefois, sa plate-forme de simulation est assez ancienne et n'a pas été mise à jour depuis de nombreuses années. En conséquence, malgré des fonctionnalités décentes, l'expérience de l'utilisateur semble dépassée.

Le meilleur simulateur de courtiers est également une application solide qui a fait ses preuves, et qui présente les mêmes avantages et inconvénients que le simulateur Investopedia.

Comparons-les l'un à l'autre.

Fonctionnalité du simulateur de trading

Savez-vous ce qui se trouve au cœur de chaque plateforme d'investissement et de négociation ?

Il s'agit du moteur graphique et de l'écran de négociation.

Si vous recherchez l'expérience la plus intuitive et la plus divertissante, Three Investeers est peut-être la meilleure. Leur outil graphique est de loin le meilleur pour analyser les mouvements intrajournaliers du marché grâce aux graphiques en chandeliers et aux prix en direct.

Best stock market simulator game comparison - trading functionality

Par exemple, avec les simulateurs Investopedia et Best Brokers, vous devez faire des allers-retours pour ouvrir un nouveau graphique d'actifs, mais avec Three Investeers, vos actifs préférés sont facilement disponibles dans la barre d'en-tête déroulante, qui est similaire à l'en-tête des stories d'Instagram.

Toutefois, si vous n'êtes pas très porté sur le day trading mais plutôt sur l'investissement à long terme, vous pouvez envisager de tester les applications Investopedia ou Best Brokers, car leurs graphiques prennent également en charge les échéances mensuelles et annuelles.

Les meilleurs outils de sélection des actions

Si vous envisagez d'acheter des actions d'une entreprise, vous devez analyser ses données financières telles que le ratio cours/bénéfice, la croissance des ventes, la marge bénéficiaire, etc.

Aucun de ces simulateurs de trading ne dispose d'une fonctionnalité d'analyse d'actions appropriée intégrée.

Les applications Investopedia et Best Brokers proposent des données fondamentales sur les actions, mais elles ne couvrent qu'une infime partie de ce qui est nécessaire à une bonne analyse.

Le simulateur de Three Investeers ne dispose d'aucune donnée fondamentale sur les actions. Il dispose d'un filtre Top Gainers et Top Losers, ce qui est pratique pour trouver des opportunités de profit en day trading, mais pas pour l'investissement en valeur.

Best stock market simulator screener apps

En outre, si vous êtes un débutant, le fait d'afficher un "ratio C/B de 68,72" à côté du logo Tesla ne vous aidera pas beaucoup.

Tout d'abord, vous aurez besoin d'une explication claire des différents ratios. Et surtout, pour analyser correctement les actions, vous devez voir les données en dynamique, et vous voulez comparer et filtrer plusieurs actifs à la fois.

Donc, à moins que vous n'ayez un abonnement à la Bloomberg Terminal (qui coûte $2,000/mo)Il est beaucoup plus pratique d'effectuer l'analyse à l'aide d'un screener d'actions dédié et de négocier (ou de simuler la négociation) à l'aide d'une application de négociation.

L'un des meilleurs filtres d'actions gratuits est Finvizoù vous pouvez filtrer les actions ayant le plus de potentiel.

Ligne de fond: Pour une analyse sérieuse, vous avez besoin d'écrans d'actions spécialisés.

Trade status and immersiveness

It’s good to see where exactly you have entered a trade on the chart and how it progresses.

Not seeing your trades on the chart is like flying a plane in the clouds without radar – it’s mundane and dangerous.

What is the best trading simulator app for day trading

Even for longer-term trading, you want to know if you are going with or against the market trend.

The Three Investeers paper trading game is one of the rare simulators that allows you to see your trades on a snappy interactive chart. You can see exactly where you entered and analyze the price action to see if there are any chart patterns around your trade or not.

With the two other simulators, you can only see your trades as lines of text in a static table.

Which app is best for live trading (Without real time price delays)?

To practice live trading, you need a trading simulator with real time prices.

The best trading app for live trading and day trading is the Three Investeers simulator as their prices are updated up to multiple times per second.

Other simulators, in comparison, feel as if they’re off-line – the prices don’t move, and the charts look frozen.

Which app is the best for live trading

If you’re more interested in practicing long-term investing, you can get by with a simulator that is updated just once every 15 minutes. However, having real-time prices is always better.

For example, seeing how Tesla stock or Oil reacts in real time to an announcement from Elon Musk will give you a better feel for how the market works. Even more important is to see how prices react in real time to the central banks’ announcements.

Why don’t all the simulators have real time prices? Having hundreds and thousands of assets firing live prices 10 times per second is highly resource-intensive. Live price streams cost a lot of money. And you need sophisticated and expensive server infrastructure to provide live trading for your users and to calculate live portfolio changes.

Which trading simulator allows you to practice 24/7?

If your trading simulator offers only stocks, you will have a short daily window to practice trading.

You’ll come home from work, open your simulator and stumble on a message like this: “Market is closed. It opens in 8 hours and 17 minutes”

If you want to trade all day long without being bound to the short stock market hours, the best option is the Three Investeers app. It has the widest selection of different assets that allow you to trade day and night, even during the weekends.

Trading simulator with the widest choice of assets to trade

The stock market is usually open from 9:30 to 16:00 Mon-Fri (EST). So if you have been dreaming about trading stocks by an infinity pool in Bali, you should probably forget about stocks and commodities.

Why?

Because when the stock market opens at 9:00 AM in New York, it is 10:00 PM in Bali. And the market closes at 5:00 in the morning Bali time.

Trading during the night will not be healthy in the long term.

Which is the best app for learning to trade and invest?

A trading simulator alone is not enough to learn investing or trading. A simulator can be useful to see how to place orders and how the basics of the market and risk management work. But there’s much more to learn if you want to be successful.

Add the fact that trading with fake money can create a false illusion of your skills, and you quickly understand that you need heaps of additional education on top of being good with a simulator.

Best stock market simulator apps to learn trading for beginners

The best educational value can be found in the Three Investeers trading school. It offers illustrated lessons starting from the very basics to the chart pattern strategies.

Unlike most other learning materials that are usually static and without illustrations, their bite-sized school is interactive. You can test your understanding with short quizzes throughout the learning process. It’s a pleasure to learn with this app. You have to buy the PRO plan to access the full school course, but it’s worth the money.

The learning section of the Investopedia simulator features a selection of market lessons linking to the articles on their website. It provides a good introduction to the financial markets as their articles are high-quality. But switching from the app to the website is not the best user experience.

Best Brokers is the weakest in terms of educational value. They have just 4 videos with some basics explained.

Best portfolio management

To learn what’s working and make necessary adjustments to your strategy, you need to have a good portfolio overview. A good portfolio screen will allow you to see all your stats at a glance and show you how you are doing currently and over different time horizons – today, this month, year to date, and all time.

Stock trading simulators with the best portfolio management features

All of the top 3 simulators have most of the necessary info available. The Three Investeers app unfortunately doesn’t allow you to switch time frames of your portfolio. The other two allow this, but they lack the live updating.

As a result, on their apps, you’ll get your performance history updated only once every other minute or after the market closure, which is quite weak.

Which is the most fun paper trading simulator?

A regular paper trading account will not keep you up at night. It will also not make you hyped and anxious in the morning before the markets open.

Why?

Because classical paper trading platforms don’t have any interactivity. You trade fake money and compete against yourself. It quickly becomes boring.

On the other hand, trading simulator games have built-in gamification elements to boost users’ motivation and make the learning process more enjoyable.

The most popular gamification element is a leaderboard where users can see how they compare against each other in the trading simulator.

The most fun trading simulator games

All of the TOP3 simulators have a leaderboard, but the Three Investeers have the most interesting and active one.

They have weekly leaderboards with a count-down timer where the users are judged by their weekly performance. As a result, even the newest members can get to the first spots, as it’s not possible for the old users to occupy the top places simply due to their accumulated game money.

From time to time, the Three Investeers also award real money prizes for the three best weekly traders.

Best simulator to learn technical analysis

If you’re serious about learning to trade, you must master technical analysis and at least a few of the most popular technical indicators.

Technical analysis is not a magic wand that will make you rich, but it helps to find trades with an increased probability of success. Also, it’s crucial for risk management.

Trading app to learn technical analysis

The only one of these apps that offers a decent set of technical analysis tools is the Three Investeers simulator.

In addition to the basic line chart, they also have candlestick charts which are the bread and butter of technical analysis. As to the indicators they have moving averages, MACD, Relative Strength Index, Bollinger bands, and 60+ other indicators. Unfortunately, they don’t yet have the Volume indicator and Fibonacci, which are very popular among traders.

Best risk management features

If there is a holy grail in trading, it’s risk management. It might sound strange, but traders with effective risk management strategies can still make money even if they lose more trades than they win.

That’s possible if their winning trades are (on average) more profitable than their losses. You don’t need a high win rate to make big returns.

mark minervini trading quote - the key to superperformance is losing the least amount when you're wrong

As a trader, you’ll inevitably have many losing positions. But if you prepare for losses – and stick to your risk management plan – they shouldn’t restrict your long-term success.

Pro trader tip: rather than focus on winning, shift your focus on not losing so much!

How can you do it? Start by learning to use stop loss and target profit orders.

Stock simulators with stop loss and target profit level functionality

Before entering a trade, you should always have an exit strategy – so that one losing trade doesn’t wipe out a significant chunk of your trading account.

Market movements can be unpredictable, and the stop loss order is one of the easiest and most efficient mechanisms that traders have to protect against excessive losses.

The Three Investeers app lets you set stop loss and target profit orders for every trade you open. That allows you to avoid unnecessary losses and learn the fundaments of risk management (especially if you couple the practice with the Risk Management chapter from their trading school.

Here’s how it looks in action:

Idea for future update: It would be helpful if you had the option to set the stops at exact price levels, instead of just percentages from the trade size.

Where can I practice trading for free?

Three Investeers Trading Simulator, Investopedia Simulator, and Best Brokers Simulator all allow you to practice trading for free.

Stock market simulator prices and free offers

If you want extra game money, full access to school or to remove the ads, you can buy the optional upgrade packages.

Unfortunately, the Investopedia simulator is filled with ads, and there is no way to turn them off, as they don’t offer a pro version.

Conclusion

It’s easy to get confused with the wide choice of simulators.

As we can conclude from this comparison, the Investopedia Simulator is the most popular one not because it’s the best one but rather because they have the top positions in Google thanks to the high domain rating of their primary website.

Three Investeers simulator has raised the bar for trading simulators, and the older leaders have a lot of work to catch up.

Three Investeers is clearly the best stock market simulator app in the market right now.

By the way, all of these trading simulators offer free versions, so go ahead and download them to see for yourself:

> Three Investeers Simulator

> Investopedia Simulator

> Best Brokers Simulator

 

Image par défaut
Daniel Ug

Cofondateur de Three Investeers et de Stock Market Simulator Game. Daniel est titulaire d'une licence en finances et technologies de l'information de la BA School of Business and Finance, en Lettonie.

Articles: 7
fr_FRFrench